Saturday, September 8, 2018

The Fourth Turning: how Millennials will save capitalism



In my last post (Let’s understand just whatsocialism means to us (redux)), I decried the misguided belief that socialism should displace the capitalist system in the industrialized West.  Old, white guys like me won’t be around to turn the tide against this trend.  It will be the Millennial generation that saves capitalism.

In Neil Howe’s book “The Fourth Turning: AnAmerican Prophecy – What the Cycles of History Tell Us About America’s Next Rendezvous with Destiny,” he outlines how four repeating generational cycles (or Turnings) determine social attitudes and ultimately govern the social contract. You can find a one page summary on his website.

Howe’s hypothesis will ring true to any student of American History as he traces the impact of events on rising generations and how each generation changes the social order. The WWII generation was in the driver’s seat for the most recent First Turning, the “American High” following WWII when the crisis of the Great Depression gave way to a period of prosperity characterized by high levels of trust in institutions. 

The Fourth Turning in this model is crisis. The Stock Market Crash of 1929 began the crisis that preceded the American High. Four generations later, Howe tells us, “Today’s Hero archetype youth, the Millennial Generation … show many traits similar to those of the G.I. youth, including rising civic engagement, improving behavior, and collective confidence.”  It is they who will develop a new social order in the wake of the financial crisis of 2008.

My contemporaries doubt this.  Like all generations of elders, we collectively take a dim view of youth that that we see as addicted to their smartphones and cowering in their safe zones.  But, I take a different view.  Studies by Big 4 accounting firm Deloitte show Millennials tend to develop values consistent with their elders once they form families.  And, they are also becoming entrepreneurs.  Their future success will be enabled by technologies their elders are, to some extent, ignoring like broadband, social media and 3-D printing.

Still not convinced? 

How about this? Businesses change their approach to the market when it’s in their best interests to do so.  Corporate values will shift as Millennials become their core customers.

In the post-industrial 21th Century, it’s getting harder to succeed purely on the basis of what you produce.  Your innovation can easily be copied, produced in a low cost factory overseas and exported to any market.  In a world where nearly every consumer can compare prices and features instantaneously, the spoils will go to the lowest cost producer not the innovator. 

To succeed in the 21st Century, corporations will have to “outbehave the competition…” according to Dov Seidman.  His book, “HOW: Why How We DoAnything Means Everything,” outlines how companies must engage all of the talents of their employees to extend enduring value to customers.  Those that succeed will be those whose behavior is aligned with its customers’ values.  They will accrue enterprise value by becoming internetworked with the communities they serve. To do so they must engage their employees by treating them fairly and giving them good reasons to be proud of what they do and where they work. 


Granted, my argument is highly speculative (or full of holes if you prefer).  The future is hard to predict.  I truly have no idea how Millennials will ensure our continued prosperity.  I simply know that every generation does so.

To buy into my argument one must have faith.  My personal faith is best captured in a quote from the late John McCain:  “Our shared values define us more than our differences.  And acknowledging those shared values can see us through our challenges today if we have the wisdom to trust them again.”

Leaders of the Fourth Turning will be those who can merge our values with our aspirations.  It is they WHO WILL LEAD!

2 comments:

  1. Unbridled capitalism and the patriarchal system need to go in this country and the millennials understand this better than previous generations. They graduated into the recession. Many of Capitalism's assumptions fly in the face of healthy ecosystems and the original intent of our Founders. I do not agree with you, John. See Otto Scharmer at MIT.

    ReplyDelete
  2. John, I love your common sense in so much that you say, but the instant you use terms like 'capitalism' and 'socialism' you descend into a realm of rhetorical flourishing entirely lacking in substance.

    You are a capitalist, yes. So am I. So is Bernie Sanders. And Jeremy Corbyn and John McDonnel. And frankly in trying to present some grand divide it's as silly as if two people in a village were arguing over whether a well should be dug a yard to the left or a yard to the right as if either one losing the argument would lead to global destruction.

    Read Adam Smith some time, seriously. One game we so-called 'socialists' love to play is to take extracts from 'Wealth of Nations' and chuck them into conversation to await the comeback 'Don't throw Marx at me!' The battle is between neoliberalism - which wouldn't have Smith's approval - and social democracy. Social democracy is nothing more than a form of capitalism more accepting of the need to have the economy serve society. Socialism would mean everything - everything, from soap to cellphones - would come to you courtesy of the state. No one is advocating that, and anyone who sees private enterprise as a nation's economic basis is a capitalist. It simply isn't under threat, and according to this kind of rhetoric only China and the USA are capitalist today. All other major players on the world stage are 'socialist' because they have healthcare based on taxation, (just about everyone); higher education funded out of taxes, (several nations such as Germany); or put a punitive tax on non-productive speculation to encourage more private wealth and bank reserves to be ploughed into R&D and industry, (Iceland, with others watching the benefits).

    Saving capitalism from what, John, for heaven's sake? From Stalinist models such as that practiced in Germany? From socialist revolutionaries like Adam Smith? Today healthcare free at the point of use, tomorrow the gulags? Seriously, chill... it's embarrassing.

    ReplyDelete